Pride & Prejudice Book Club Podcast

Pirates and Prejudice - By Kara Louise

Set sail with us, Book Clubbers! This week we’re talking Pirates and Prejudice by Kara Louise, a swashbuckling Austen variation that is exactly as bonkers as the title suggests. We’ve got Darcy going full emo post-rejection, Elizabeth getting stranded on an island, a wildly convoluted pirate impersonation plot, and yes…plenty of over-the-top swashbuckling pirate antics!
We had a lot of fun unpacking this intentionally silly, trope-heavy adventure, even if the only thing really Austen about it is the names. Along the way, we chat about the limits of leadership (does being a good landowner qualify you to captain a ship?), the question of whether men and women can be “just friends,” and the difference between regret and curiosity when we look back at our life choices.
This book might not be packed with depth, but it gave us plenty to talk about! So grab your eyepatch and suspend your disbelief—this is going to be fun!
---
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

More Than You Know - By Jennifer Altman

It’s hard to surprise us with a book premise, but this week’s story pulled it off!
We’re discussing More Than You Know by Jennifer Altman, a Pride and Prejudice variation with a twist we’ve never seen before: Elizabeth is paired with Bingley (!!), and Darcy is hiding a mysterious secret that had us eagerly turning the pages. The setup felt fresh and full of promise, and honestly, that kind of originality is getting harder to come by 😜
But oh, Darcy. Even with a sympathetic backstory, his relentless stubbornness in the second half of the book really wore on us. We unpack what worked, what left us a little frustrated, and what felt emotionally authentic for the character.
Plus, a brief detour into Sense and Sensibility, where Emilie’s teenage daughter challenges the moral integrity of Edward Ferrars (and… we might just have to agree with her).
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Done For The Best - By Amy D'Orazio

Is it ever okay to lie to "protect" someone? That’s the big question we wrestle with this week as we dive into Amy D’Orazio’s Done for the Best. In this Pride and Prejudice variation, Darcy makes a very bold choice: after Elizabeth loses her memory, he lets her believe they’re engaged—even though they’re not. Cue all the ethical dilemmas. Was it selfless? Was it selfish? And is “done for the best” ever really a good enough excuse?
Along the way, we veer into real-life relationship territory—when is omission just privacy, and when is it actually deception? Emilie shares her personal litmus test for honesty (kind, true, and necessary), while Alicia opens up about the tricky gray areas of trust and how much we really owe people in terms of full disclosure. We also dive into the awkward social minefield of pregnancy etiquette (please don’t ask unless you know), reflect on maternal instinct versus medical advice, and detour through ’90s movie nostalgia, featuring everything from While You Were Sleeping to Flubber. Turns out, memory loss isn’t the only thing that’s complicated.
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Author Interview: Elizabeth Adams on Sons of Pemberley

We couldn’t wait to welcome Elizabeth Adams back for her third visit to the podcast, and trust us—she did not disappoint! This time, we dive deep into her epic reimagining Sons of Pemberley, a richly layered story that explores what might have happened if Lady Anne Darcy had survived. Spoiler: everything changes.
In this conversation, we cover everything from character arcs and alternate timelines to the surprising ways a book can take on a life of its own. Emilie and Elizabeth swap insights about Lady Anne’s transformation into the emotional center of the story, Lady Maryanne’s unexpected emergence as a featured character, and how friendship, adoption, and beauty are intricately woven throughout the narrative. There’s also a healthy dose of behind-the-scenes author talk—deleted scenes, writing during toddler nap times, and the pressures of crafting a dual-timeline novel with dozens of characters.
Whether you’ve read Sons of Pemberley once or five times, you’ll love this peek into the heart and mind behind the story. And if you haven’t read it yet… consider this your sign!
---
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Sons of Pemberley - By Elizabeth Adams

In this episode of The Pride and Prejudice Book Club, we dive into Elizabeth Adams’ sweeping alternate universe tale, Sons of Pemberley. This rich reimagining had us reflecting on everything from the impact of childhood relationships to the quieter tragedies and triumphs of our lives.
We loved discussing the novel’s unique premise—what if Lady Anne Darcy never died? That single change creates an entire cast of new and altered characters, and a world where Darcy doesn’t arrive at Netherfield alone but with a whole crew of siblings, cousins, and childhood friends. While Darcy and Elizabeth are still at the heart of the story, the emotional center here belongs to Lady Anne and George Darcy, whose heartbreaking and beautifully written love story had us both tearing up more than once.
We explored how the book's flashbacks added depth and poignancy, particularly through themes of grief, partnership, and the complicated bonds of family. While we wanted more from some characters’ arcs, there’s no denying how much we appreciated the attention to emotional realism and generational influence.
And yes, we also went on a few tangents—this is us, after all! Superhero fatigue, cousin dynamics, the eternal quest for more stories about happily married people working through real issues... it’s all in there. Join us as we reflect on the joys of slow-burn stories, emotionally intelligent writing, and the power of a well-drawn supporting cast.
--
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Pride & Prejudice (2005) – 20th Anniversary Special

Book Clubbers, we have a very special treat for you this week! We had the distinct pleasure of seeing the 20th Anniversary re-release of Joe Wright’s Pride and Prejudice (2005), starring Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen — and we were so excited afterward that we immediately recorded our thoughts right there in the car (please excuse the less-than-perfect sound quality!).
We talk about the moments that we still love, and get a little nitpicky about some of the choices that were made, but at the end of the day, our love for this adaptation holds strong. Pride and Prejudice forever ❤️
---
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Sole Mates - By Melanie Rachel

What if your soulmate was revealed from the moment you first dance with them? 
This week on The Pride and Prejudice Book Club, Alicia and Emilie dive into Sole Mates by Melanie Rachel—a delightful short story (seriously, maybe an hour of your time) that gives Lizzy and Darcy a literal soul connection… and matching foot burns. 😳🔥🥿
We talk about whether love can really blossom in a single night, the stories we tell ourselves (and write in our journals, plus the questionable reliability of memories.
👉 Note: You can only get Sole Mates by subscribing to Melanie Rachel’s newsletter—so if you're curious, sign up ASAP!
Book Clubbers, we promise this episode will leave your heart a little lighter and maybe even inspire you to dig out those old journals…
🎧 Listen wherever you get your podcasts!
—
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Bluebells in the Mourning - By KaraLynne Mackrory

This week, we read Bluebells in the Mourning by KaraLynne Mackrory, a Pride & Prejudice variation that opens with an emotional shock: Lydia is dead, and everything changes. The story brushes up against themes of grief and healing, but ultimately keeps things soft and comforting, with lots of Darcy-and-Lizzy time and a surprisingly sweet arc for Mr. and Mrs. Bennet.
We talk about what worked (Georgiana playing matchmaker, Wickham’s comeuppance, low angst all around) and what didn’t quite land (questionable logic leaps, miscommunication galore, and a slightly emo Darcy). There’s also tangents about confiding in near-strangers, and whether it’s better to always support your friends…or call them out.
If you’re in the mood for a variation that’s light on angst and wraps up neatly, this one might be for you!
---
🎶 Music Credit: Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.---
📚 Curious what we’ll be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com---
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter
 

A Shared History - By Abigail Sheffield

What if Elizabeth and Darcy had met before Netherfield—only for things to go terribly wrong?
This week, we’re talking about A Shared History by Abigail Sheffield, a dual-timeline Pride and Prejudice variation that asks: can you rebuild something beautiful after a painful ending?
With strong Persuasion energy and a narrative that moves between past and present, this story explores what happens when deep hurt meets enduring love. We dive into all the messy, relatable parts of learning to trust again, what it takes to offer a second chance, and how to know when someone’s really changed.
We also take a few side quests along the way—into Little Women adaptations, pre-pandemic moviegoing, and quick stops at Grey’s Anatomy, Harry Potter, and Barbie. 
This variation gave us all the emotional complexity we love in a second-chance romance—and reminded us just how satisfying it is when Elizabeth and Darcy finally find their way back to each other.
P.S. Be honest—how did you feel about Emma Watson as Meg? Let us know in the comments!
 
🎵 Music Credit:
Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!

Some Particular Evil - By Emilia Stratford

We’re back with a full-blown Austen murder mystery this week, and honestly? We were into it. Alicia and Emilie dive into Some Particular Evil by Amelia Stratford—a gripping “who-done-it” where Elizabeth goes full detective mode and Darcy’s on the run (and in disguise, no less).
We talk red herrings, a suspiciously helpful Colonel Fitzwilliam, and a truly unhinged Anne de Bourgh. Plus, how believable was Lizzy and Darcy’s letter-fueled romance? And did the secret boxing subplot actually go anywhere? (Spoiler: we were waiting for someone to get punched.)
The conversation also takes a thoughtful turn when Lady Anne’s storyline opens up a personal discussion about postpartum depression and the quiet networks of support women build for each other. And yes—somehow we end up reminiscing about the Clue movie and old-school VHS commercials. If you ever rewound your favorite 90s movie with a pencil, this episode is for you.
It’s twisty, it’s layered, it’s not Death Comes to Pemberley—and we’re here for it.
 
🎵 Music Credit:Pride & Prejudice Book Club Theme composed, performed, and arranged by Megan Mason.
📚 Curious what we will be reading next? See a list of upcoming books at prideandprejudicebookclub.com!
➡️ Follow us on Facebook and Instagram, or sign up for our newsletter at https://www.prideandprejudicebookclub.com/newsletter!